Saturday, August 12, 2006

Baseball Managers: A Recyclable Commodity?

It's a commonplace that major league managers are fired by one team only to be hired by another. The managerial history of the current crop of managers is given below. Here's an overview:

  • 12 of the 30 managers have managed only 1 team
  • 9 have managed 2 different teams
  • 6 have managed 3 different teams
  • 3 have managed 4 different teams.

A closer look:

  • 40 percent (12) of the present managers have managed only 1 team
  • the other 60 percent (18) have managed an average of 2-2/3 different teams (a total of 48 managing stints)
  • 8 of those 48 managing stints have spanned 10 or more seasons; 17 stints have spanned 5 or more seasons
  • the 18 team-switching managers have switched 30 times (1-2/3 times per manager)
  • the average gap between stints has been 3 seasons
  • 40 percent (12) of the switches were immediate (during a season or in consecutive seasons)
  • the immediate switches involved 50 percent (9) of the managers who have managed 2 or more teams.

Are major-league managers a recyclable commodity? I report, you decide.
__________

The managers and their teams and seasons (including partial seasons):

Felipe Alou

Montreal Expos, 1992-2001
San Francisco Giants, 2003-

Dusty Baker

San Francisco Giants, 1993-2002
Chicago Cubs, 2003-

Buddy Bell

Detroit Tigers, 1996-1998
Colorado Rockies, 2000-2002
Kansas City Royals, 2005-

Bruce Bochy

San Diego Padres, 1995-

Bobby Cox

Atlanta Braves, 1978-1981
Toronto Blue Jays, 1982-1985
Atlanta Braves, 1990-

Terry Francona

Philadelphia Phillies, 1997-2000
Boston Red Sox, 2004-

Ron Gardenhire

Minnesota Twins, 2002-

Phil Garner

Milwaukee Brewers, 1992-1999
Detroit Tigers, 2000-2002
Houston Astros, 2004-

Joe Gerardi

Florida Marlins, 2006-

John Gibbons

Toronto Blue Jays, 2004-

Ozzie Guillen

Chicago White Sox, 2004-

Mike Hargrove

Cleveland Indians, 1991-1999
Baltimore Orioles, 2000-2003
Seattle Mariners, 2005-

Clint Hurdle

Colorado Rockies, 2002-

Tony LaRussa

Chicago White Sox, 1979-1985
Oakland Athletics, 1985-1995
St. Louis Cardinals, 1996-

Jim Leyland

Pittsburgh Pirates, 1986-1996
Florida Marlins, 1997-1998
Colorado Rockies, 1999
Detroit Tigers, 2006-

Grady Little

Boston Red Sox, 2002-2003
Los Angeles Dodgers, 2006-

Ken Macha

Oakland Athletics, 2003-

Joe Maddon

California/Anaheim Angels, 1996, 1999
Tampa Bay Devil Rays, 2006-

Charlie Manuel

Cleveland Indians, 2000-2002
Philadelphia Phillies, 2005-

Bob Melvin

Seattle Mariners, 2003-2004
Arizona Diamondbacks, 2005-

Jerry Narron

Texas Rangers, 2000-2001
Cincinnati Reds, 2005-

Sam Perlozzo

Baltimore Orioles, 2005-

Willie Randolph

New York Mets, 2005-

Frank Robinson

Cleveland Indians, 1995-1997
San Francisco Giants, 1981-1984
Baltimore Orioles, 1988-1991
Montreal Expos/Washington Nationals, 2002-

Mike Scioscia

Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels, 2000-

Buck Showalter

New York Yankees, 1992-1995
Arizona Diamondbacks, 1998-2000
Texas Rangers, 2003-

Joe Torre

New York Mets, 1977-1981
Atlanta Braves, 1982-1984
St. Louis Cardinals, 1990-1995
New York Yankees, 1996-

Jim Tracy

Los Angeles Dodgers, 2001-2005
Pittsburgh Pirates, 2006-

Eric Wedge

Cleveland Indians, 2003-

Ned Yost

Milwaukee Brewers, 2003-